The Big Five
In my eyes, the Belbin team roles aren’t necessarily suited
for our team. We are trying to mould our team members into categories where
they don’t fit, none other than for the sake of having to. If anything, we have
a coordinator. This is the person who often initiates conversation between us
and organises team meetings or skype calls. Even then, I think we have more of
a Laissez-faire leadership style; we all contribute to the decision making to some
extent. Some might also argue a democratic/precipitative leadership style, but
with many of our decisions being unanimous, it’s a little tricky to make that
call.
I see many (if not all) members in our team as a team worker
- yet none of us are particularly indecisive. Our editor also could be a
completer finisher, but again this role doesn’t necessarily match the traits of
this particular team member. I do not see anyone specifically suited to plant,
shaper, monitor-evaluator or resource investigator. According to the Belbin
team theory we are missing both “ideas” roles in our team, yet we are
generating plenty of ideas. Maybe this is because we all put forward our own
ideas and discuss them amongst ourselves. Though none of us fit into the
specific characteristics of each Belbin role, I believe we all collectively
make up a small part of the equation. Perhaps this is why I think the
Laissez-faire style of leadership suits us well. Though the Belbin theory of
teamwork it’s a great baseline for effective teamwork, I don’t think it’s
necessary for a team to be successful.
An article I read suggests that all effective teamwork needs
is the 'Big five': “The core components of teamwork include team
leadership, mutual
performance monitoring, backup behaviour, adaptability, and team
orientation.” (Salas et al. 2005).
performance monitoring, backup behaviour, adaptability, and team
orientation.” (Salas et al. 2005).
Our team arguably offers some of these elements too. Each of us present with
leadership qualities, while respectively monitoring each other’s performance
and proving very adaptable. We had unanimously agreed on using utilitarianism for
our moral theory. Our survey results showed much support for principlism,
bearing this in mind we made the decision to change our moral theory while part
way through writing – this screams adaptability.
We are all leaders in our own right - our team members have
all been given roles in areas where they hold strengths. Whether that be due to
personal knowledge or writing discussions about the topics we had researched.
Personally, I am the editor, stemming from my other team members believing that
I am a strong and concise writer.
At times we got behind, especially towards the end of assignment
two. Several team members had a number of assignments due that same weekend.
Nonetheless, that’s nothing which couldn’t be solved by open communication and
delegation. Between instant messaging available on Facebook, weekly Skype
meetings and more recently messaging over Google Docs, we’ve always had a
platform to update other members of our team on our progress, or lack thereof.
Is it possible that no one can justify the characteristics
of an ‘effective’ team? After all, it is rather subjective. There are a number
of different variables in play - from the size of the team, to the qualities
each member contributes. All teams are unique; not every team is going to fit
into a category. In fact, it’s arguable that many teams won’t. So, why should
we?
References
Salas, E., Sims, D. E. & Burke, C. S. (2005). Is there a “Big Five” in Teamwork? 36(5). https://doi.org/10.1177/1046496405277134
Salas, E., Sims, D. E. & Burke, C. S. (2005). Is there a “Big Five” in Teamwork? 36(5). https://doi.org/10.1177/1046496405277134
Comments